Gauthic Times: The Bill Gauthier Newsletter #199, or Is There Anybody Alive Out There?

Hello, friends.

This past week was all over the place, wasn’t it? More Boston Children’s Hospital trips, a holiday, watching the looney place the world has become, and teaching in the 21st century all make a guy tired! But now I’m here and you’re here and we have some stuff to talk about.

Welcome to the 199th installment of Gauthic Times, the newsletter about my writing, my life, and musings about fun and writing. If you’re a reader who subscribes via Substack, my website, or Patreon, your encouragement helps motivate me. Feel free to reach out through the comments or on social media. I’m thankful to have any audience.

Thank you.

Supporting creators is so important right now. As such, I would love if you became a paid-Patron on my Patreon.

Support the arts and this writing journey…

Patrons get exclusive daily check-ins about works-in-progress including the actual names of my works-in-progress and not just codenames. I also show art that I do.

You can also buy me a coffee through Ko-Fi. 

The Monster in the Closet is out now! Order it here!

You can also grab my novel Echoes on the Pond, my collection Catalysts, or my novellas Alice on the Shelf and Shadowed if you haven’t already. And if you’ve read them, please consider leaving a review on Amazon or Goodreads, and wherever else books are sold and reviewed.

You could also read the first draft of Four Moons on Patreon. It’s a werewolf story and I think it’s fun. It is a first draft, though, so be kind if you choose to read it. If you’re interested, Patrons at the $5 tier and above have access but there is also a way to buy into the whole book for $13.99. You don’t have to be a long-term Patron for that second option.

***

More editing Four Moons throughout this week. I’m about 30 or less pages from the end of the first draft. I’m hoping to be through it this weekend, early this week at the latest. There are notes like:

and this one:

It’s part of the process. The goal is always to tune the strings so you can have the best sound possible. In terms of a werewolf story, I don’t know if there’s anything new in the book, but I hope it’s entertaining. I feel like I can get it there, which is a great feeling.

***

***

About two weeks ago, I got a reply to a post I made on Bluesky. Last week, I received a different reply from a different account. I do not believe either of “engagement” was by humans. As such, I did not reply.

This is the world I find myself in. I write essays and newsletters that are, ostensibly, about my books, my writing, my life, my thoughts, and my musings all in the hope that readers may respond. I hope they’ll enjoy the writing and will buy my books, subscribe, join my Patreon, and engage. That’s the hope for all creatives, isn’t it? To establish an audience that’s excited about your work and who may wish to engage (respectively) regarding it.[1] It’s a lot to ask for but it’s part of the social contract, right?

So when I got a notification that there was a reply to my post saying that Gauthic Times 197, with my essay “Ideas Are Not the Problem” was out, along with links for the places one can read my newsletter, I was happy. It’s rare for me, still. Likes? Sure. Actual, human engagement? Still not exactly common.

The response was: “If ideas aren’t the problem, which runs out first for you: time or energy? 🤔 Asking for every writer sitting on a folder of brilliant first chapters.”

This sounded good. Naturally, I wanted to know who asked such a question. As I perused their profile and posts, I began to believe that maybe this was not a person. I already wondered since the reply to my post was itself vague without being off-topic. It has a cadence that just doesn’t sound right to me.

I wasn’t sure if I should engage or not. On the one hand, if it was a reader trying to reach out, alienating them might be bad (not that I don’t already alienate people with my political, nerdy, or silly essays in the newsletter). On the other hand, engaging with robots on social media doesn’t appeal to me. Eventually, I did what I always do.

I forgot about it.

Life is a river that flows and carries one with it regardless of if they want to go and life just made me forget about it.

Until last week. I did my typical social media post about that week’s Gauthic Times newsletter (198, “Just Have Fun”) and received another reply, this one from a different account:

“Balancing fun with the grit of storytelling is such an underrated topic! Did a specific scene or milestone in your current WIP spark this edition’s focus on keeping writing fun?”

Again, it sounds like an interested person but I felt like something was off about it. It’s vague in its specificity. The other thing I thought, too, was if a reader were to engage, why not do it at one of the places the newsletter is posted? Between my website, Patreon, and Substack (and Tumblr, I think, too), there are plenty of places for a reader to comment. Some actually do![2] Not that a reply on social media is bad, because it’s not. It might even get more people to read my writing. But something just felt off.

Another strange thing is that both of these incidents happened on Bluesky. After the Great Twitter Collapse of 2023 (or whatever year it was), I—like many other Creatives—joined a bunch of social media sites. For a short time, Bluesky seemed like it would be a great place. Like most socmed, it’s just a place now. I’ve had some good engagement there, but I’ve also had good engagement on Threads and Instagram, too.

In looking up that second account, I saw that a bestselling science fiction writer had a whole back-and-forth with the account and the account’s responses only solidified, in my mind, that the account is an AI bot.

Would there be any damage in replying to an AI bot? I honestly don’t know. There’s no harm in having a conversation with my armpit, either, but I don’t make a habit of it. It doesn’t sit right with me, though.

And what if I’m wrong? What if these accounts are well-meaning, anonymous people/companies trying to actually engage and help the writer? What if I’m shooting myself in the foot?

Honestly, I don’t think it will bother me. A few weeks further back, I did get engagement from an actual person who has several horror-related newsletters. It was good, it was personal, and it was from one of the sources of my newsletter. When I looked into them, I saw they were legitimate and had interesting things to say. I replied and have been a subscriber to their newsletter since.

That’s what engagement is about. A human connection based on the willingness to reach out and converse. It’s a connection to the art, the creativity, and it’s the thing we crave as creators and audiences.

Many others have said, “Fuck AI,” and I’m certainly with them. It was already difficult to know if people actually resonated with my work or if they were just trying to scam me or fuck with me, and now I have to worry about robots doing the same thing.

At least my stories are still there. I just hope that readers—real blood-and-flesh humans—will be, too.

***

That’s this week’s newsletter. Thank you so much for subscribing, reading, and for your support. Be safe out there, friends.

If you’d like to be a part of making my dream of creating full-time a reality, become a Patron on my Patreon, which has a lot more information about my works-in-progress and the books I’ll be querying, including titles and some simple, non-spoiler details.

Don’t forget to share this newsletter with others and consider a paid subscription.

You can also tip/donate on Ko-Fi.

Get my novels The Monster in the Closet and Echoes on the Pond, my collection Catalysts, and my novellas Alice on the Shelf and Shadowed!

If you haven’t left a review on Amazon, Goodreads, or anyplace else for the books, particularly The Monster in the Closet and Echoes on the Pond, please consider doing so. This greatly helps.

Thank you for subscribing!


[1] I’m trying really hard to not to use the term “content.” I’m not opposed to the term, per se, but I do feel like it’s cheapened the work Creatives put into their art. Creatives have always made content but in recent times the term has become synonymous with lower common denominator crap and, as P.J. Proby said, “I am an artist and I should be exempt from shit.”

[2] THANK YOU!!!


Discover more from Gautham: Bill Gauthier.com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply